tman93's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Elastic Guys]

Ummm....

I'm also a stick animator, and I've got to say that this just doesn't deserve the score it has. The movements were really bad, as they were really choppy. The way you draw your sticks is just bad. Proportions are just not there, as his knees are in the wrong spot. Learn how to draw a stick.

Keep practicing though with sticks and you may become great.

DikkopStudios responds:

Ok thanks. But if it doesn't deserve the score it has, why do I have a daily third? Just like ur Entanglement movie?
Oh well thanks for the advice and I have to admit u draw sticks alot better but it's all like Terkoiz' stuff. I like to be original, I have my own style. Most people like it :)
If becoming great means that I have to animate like jcamelo, terkoiz etc I wont strive to that. If becoming great means that my movies get a really score and alot of attention, that'll be my goal.

[Project Gladiator]

YAY C:

Awesome work steel C:

I saw this on antiup a while ago <_<...

anywho, keep it up mang!

SteelCold responds:

Yessir Tman :D. Thanks

[TLTFT 2008 Round 3 Collab]

C:::::::

I liked your background Hawk C;

Tolins owned sum tush though. Hopefully I'll be able to join this soon.

[|~SpeedAnim:WheresWaldo~|]

I love this

Even though this is just practice, it shows just how good you can be when you make a full out movie. Atm, i'm searching for Snow snow for lucy everywhere, i've seen the trailer about 20 times C:

I'm a big fan of yours mr. spikevalentine. may i call myself one of your number 1 fans?

You put a thoughtful message in almost every single one of your animations. You always put a theme in these, and it just rocks!

10/10 5/5
awesome job mate.

[Strider - Unfinished]

Great job

Coming from a fellow stick animator...

I will only judge you on what's there, for i feel that that's right.

The story had a huge say in my score, it's really cool, and when the viewer see's all the posters about Strider on the wall, the story kicks in more. I also love your style on animation, it's just like a cartoon with all the words coming out of the actions "Ratatata" and "Boom".

That caught my eye, but it may become a bit annoying in a 3 minute animation (just for suggestions).

Anyways, awesome job.

Btw, did you draw the backgrounds? What's with the pixelated stuff?

10/10, 5/5

[StickDude Killing Arena 4]

Overrated

I am also a stick animator, so I'll say that first.

I really don't understand how this animation has such a high score. The actual stick animation is bad. The way they run is just horrible. Although your effects make up for your crappy stick movements, I still give it a 6/10 3/5

This is just way overrated.

[|~SpeedAnim:OscarPlease~|]

wow

I love every single message you give the viewers in your animations.

amazingly done. I can't wait for that 45 minute animation dude. srsly.

[Irod Bad!]

lmao

excellent parody. i got a metal gear awesome feeling from it C:

loved the "i am iron man dududududdudud"

pure <3

[RE:]

eh...

I am also a stick animator, so I don't have anything against this movie.

There were several errors that were present though.

-Your sticks resized WAY to much
-Your sticks are HORRIBLY drawn
-Your sticks have CHOPPY movements

also the sound quality was way to high.

take your time with stick animations. please.

[Naruto VS Sauske]

Good try.

As a fellow stick animator, I loved what I saw. Except your movements, lack of background, and that it was shaky the whole entire time.

You need to learn how to anticipate movements, and use exagerations with movements too.

I'm giving you a 5 because the animation was there, but not all was perfect for a 10.

enigon301 responds:

OMG UR TMAN!!!!!!!!!!!! DUDE THANKS FOR THE ADVICE APRECIATE IT. XD